Human rights law dna profiling a comparative analysis law essay

These genetic materials are typically found on items of: Should racial profiling be accepted as a law enforcement practice. In England and Wales the law was changed in to allow the indefinite retention of all this information, but in December the European Court of Human Rights found unanimously that this practice was in breach of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Human DNA profiling BillPrivacy The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of DailyO. Data-sharing, involving the transfer of information across international borders, is also on the increase. The prescribed form for collection of data from criminals has a column for "caste", which experts fear could lead to profiling of certain castes and population groups.

Additional safeguards are needed for people who give their DNA to the police on a voluntary basis during the course of an investigation: Thus there will always be a real practical limit to how many crimes can be solved using DNA.

The main issues are outlined in more detail below. This requires independent oversight as well as the regular publication of public information about the size, costs and effectiveness of the database in solving crimes.

Each of us is qualified to a high level in our area of expertise, and we can write you a fully researched, fully referenced complete original answer to your essay question. DNA evidence is not foolproof and mistakes can be made in laboratories or in court.

Expanding DNA databases to include many persons who have merely been arrested represents a significant shift in which the line between guilty and innocent is becoming blurred.

In order to measure quality, quantity and concentration of the DNA sample, optical density readings are taken by a spectrophotometer Science Learning Hub, ; which is a vital element of Forensic science, to prove the reliability of the DNA, as a source of evidence.

Routine cross-border speculative searching of crime scene DNA profiles against stored DNA profiles from individuals arrested in other countries is therefore likely to throw up many more false matches than if such searches are restricted to one country or limited to only a small number of profiles.

However, individuals who have been wrongly convicted of a crime do not need their DNA profile to be on a database in order to be exonerated: Children who have been separated from an adult for their own protection could also be tracked down by someone with access to a DNA database if the adult has a sample of their DNA taken from an old toothbrush, for exampleor who shares part of their DNA profile because they are related to them.

The benefits of DNA databases in solving crimes must be weighed against these downsides. On the other hand, the enactment of racial profiling seemingly exempts members of specific racial identities or ethnic backgrounds from random law enforcement procedures such as being stopped in traffic.

Why Human DNA Profiling Bill can put Indians in danger

Mass screens are rarely effective unless there is a specific reason to test a specific group of people for example, the suspect is known to work in a particular office and they can lead to loss of trust in policing in targeted communities.

Collecting DNA from foreign visitors would add further to the costs and difficulties and could have negative impacts on people willing to travel to the country. Introduction to comparative politics, Boston. Some of the relevant issues are considered in more detail below. Police can also collect biological samples from suspects, usually by scraping some cells from inside their cheek.

Prior to examining the various demerits of racial profiling, it is extremely important to evaluate its meaning. Forensic science creates a reliable source of evidence and is able to identify unknown criminals in crime scene, through their genetic information.

It is also critically important to highlight the fact that most of the advantages associated with racial profiling are extremely flimsy and as such, its contribution towards the betterment of society is very minimal.

How does a DNA database help to solve more crimes. Again, a match may indicate that the individual may be a suspect for the crime.

When biological samples are collected by the police from a crime scene or an individual, they are sent to a laboratory for analysis. In addition, bigger databases — and more comparisons between DNA profiles stored in different countries — increase the likelihood of false matches, as described above.

However, even a rape case may not be straightforward: These can waste police time following false leads, even if they do not lead to miscarriages of justice.

What Are Some Advantages and Disadvantages of Using DNA Analysis to Aid Law Enforcement in Crime?

After arresting Jakobetz, the law enforcement officials sent a sample DNA blood for DNA analysis. A comparison analysis was then conducted between the blood of Jakobetz and the semen that was found in the body of the said victim after the crime occurred.

Why Human DNA Profiling Bill can put Indians in danger Kuwait enacted a law that makes DNA profiling of its citizens and foreign nationals living in the country mandatory. The Human DNA.

DNA Databases and Human Rights

Criminal Law And The Criminal Justice System Words | 10 Pages. 10 INTRODUCTION Criminal Law attempts to balance the rights of individuals to freedom from interference with person or property, and society’s need for order.

Free Science essays

Parven, Khaleda, Forensic use of DNA information: human rights, privacy and other challenges, Doctor of Philosophy thesis, Faculty CAQDAS Computer-Assisted Qualitative Data Analysis Software CODIS Combined DNA Index System ECtHR European Court of Human Rights EDNAP European DNA Profiling.

The DNA Profiling Bill, was introduced with an objective to “enhance protection of people in the society and administration of justice, analysis of DNA found at the scene of crime, of the victim or offender has been used to establish identity”.

Individuals rights are significantly effected throughout genetic profiling, with the choice of DNA tests not being available, creating inequality and a lack of rights in bodily privacy, while genetic privacy shows the unlawfulness of employment, which require DNA test, but use it in the wrong aspects; and behavioural privacy, which allows a simple DNA test of a volunteer or victim to condemn the individual of a past.

DNA Databases and Human Rights Human rights law dna profiling a comparative analysis law essay
Rated 4/5 based on 82 review
Argumentative Essay: Racial Profiling